Me, my Self and I

by Annemieke on July 30, 2010

Post image for Me, my Self and I

The ‘self’ is a concept that I know best by the writings of Carl Jung.

I don’t know if my understanding of the concept is right, but I thought I more or less ‘got it’.

But as mentioned in my previous post, David Bohm also talks about the ‘self’. And somehow I got the feeling he gives it a different meaning.

In another post I will go into the meaning I think Jung gives to it, but in this post I want to look into the definition of Bohm.

I versus Me

First he makes a clear distinction between I and me. The ‘I’ is in control, while the ‘me’ is limited. The ‘I’ makes the choices, while everything just happens to ‘me’.

A child must begin regarding himself as the great I am because he sees himself as the center of the universe from which all action flows. Then he learns from society he’s only little me. They say: Who do you think you are?


Reflex system versus creative expression

The next differentiation Bohm makes is between, what he calls, the repetitive reflex system and a natural desire of creative expression. Everyone has this creative desire, but when the repetitive reflex system is more strong, the creativity is most likely not able to develop enough.

People are conditioned to stay in the repetitive reflex system, which has the tendency to defend itself and to keep you in it.

One of the greatest dangers of creativity is producing for a reward.

If the child is rewarded for producing a desired result, this will automatically throw him into the reflex system. It gives a very powerful emotional pressure to continue there.

Creative children do not need a reward, they don’t need to be told they are good, because the creative free play is a reward in itself. It makes them learn to rely on their own inner knowledge.

Self and Ego

I don’t think the definition of Bohm of the ‘self’ is the same as the definition of Jung. I will go into that into another post, but as I see it at this point, the definition of Bohm might be what is called the ‘ego’ by Jung.

Annemieke

What is the Self?

July 27, 2010
Thumbnail image for What is the Self?

This week I found another interview with David Bohm. Somewhere in that interview he talks about why we need the space to develop creativity. He wrote about that in the book Science, Order and Creativity and I already have several posts about one chapter of that book. The chapter states that creativity is very important, [...]

Read more →

The 7 Links Challenge

July 21, 2010
Thumbnail image for The 7 Links Challenge

Last week on Problogger there was a great challenge. It was a 7 link challenge, to write a post with links to 7 posts that fit into 7 themes. I thought that was a perfect way to go over my posts again to see which ones I could bring together in one post. 1. Your [...]

Read more →

The Development of Creativity

July 18, 2010
Thumbnail image for The Development of Creativity

Last week I had a guestpost on the blog Thoughtwrestling about the place of creativity in human development as a whole. In the post I also mentioned how I see the development of creativity itself. I wrote another post on that before, where I used my model of development to describe creativity in different forms [...]

Read more →

The Form and Content of Thought

June 27, 2010
Thumbnail image for The Form and Content of Thought

After I finished my previous post, one line kept buzzing in my head. ‘Mathematics is about thought, not the content of thought, but the form in which we can hold the content of thought.’ And at the same time I was searching for a picture to visualise how that could be. Sort of structures that [...]

Read more →

Thought is about Becoming, not Being

June 26, 2010
Thumbnail image for Thought is about Becoming, not Being

A few weeks ago I got a book from the library that really fascinated me. And especially one chapter was so interesting that I wanted to write several blogposts about it. But while doing that, I found out that this book was an older version. And there was a more recent version that had an [...]

Read more →

The Danger of Praise and Reward as Fuel for Creativity

June 14, 2010
Thumbnail image for The Danger of Praise and Reward as Fuel for Creativity

This post is going to be centred around several sentences. A few lines from the book Science, Order and Creativity. The moment I read those lines, I really felt this was true. By analyzing it here in this post, I hope to emphasise the very important distinctions that I think are essential. I will let [...]

Read more →

Inner Drive or Navigation from Outside

June 9, 2010
Thumbnail image for Inner Drive or Navigation from Outside

In this post I want to see how the conclusions from the previous post fit the model I use on this blog. There are many ways to look at it, but for now I want to focus on the main point of that post: the need for approval. As children we are sensitive to authority. [...]

Read more →

How Creativity is Blocked by the Need for Approval

June 7, 2010
Thumbnail image for How Creativity is Blocked by the Need for Approval

Creativity is a natural potential energy in humans, which becomes destructive if it is blocked. This is a conclusion of a chapter in the book that I want to review in this post. The first part of the above conclusion says that creativity is an inherent characteristic in humans, which is shown by experiments with [...]

Read more →

Creativity in the Whole of Life

June 5, 2010
Thumbnail image for Creativity in the Whole of Life

After I wrote my previous post, I read the chapter ‘Creativity in the whole of life’ for the second time. The chapter from a book called ‘Science, Order and Creativity’. And this time I was even more convinced that it reflects my thoughts on many things that I want to write about on this blog. [...]

Read more →

English Books in Dutch Libraries

June 3, 2010
Thumbnail image for English Books in Dutch Libraries

I love books that are non-fiction. It is not that I do not like fiction, sometimes I do, but most of the books that I read in my life were non-fiction. I used to spend many hours in our library looking for answers to questions I had, taking as much books home as I could. [...]

Read more →

Patterns of Meaning that Develop over Time

May 23, 2010
Thumbnail image for Patterns of Meaning that Develop over Time

This past week I had been thinking about information. How ‘real’ is our knowledge? My thoughts on that went into many directions (as usual) but I kept coming back to something the writer David Foster Wallace said in an interview. I came across this writer because several people mentioned him. The first time was a [...]

Read more →